Two Lubricants, Different Strengths
Choosing between silicone lube and water-based lube often comes down to how you plan to use it. Both reduce friction and enhance comfort, but their textures, staying power, and compatibility with toys differ. Promescent offers a Silicone Lube and a Water Lube, each made in the USA with high-grade ingredients. This comparison focuses on the real differences so you can pick the one that fits your routine.
Texture and Feel
The main difference you'll notice is consistency.
- Silicone Lube: A thicker formula that provides a smooth, long-lasting glide. It is odorless, colorless, and paraben-free.
- Water Lube: A lighter, greaseless feel that is also odorless, colorless, and paraben-free. It rinses off easily with water.
What the Catalog Confirms
- Silicone Lube: Silicone-based lube is perfect for longer lasting sex or masturbation and does not dry out quickly. If you want a lubricant that stays slick without reapplying, silicone lube is a strong choice.

Silicone Lube - Water Lube: Water-based lube is ideal and safe for use during solo masturbation with adult toys made from silicone materials. Water lube is the safer option if you use silicone toys, as silicone lube can degrade silicone surfaces.

Water Lube
Longevity and Cleanup
Silicone lube does not dry out quickly, making it suitable for longer sessions or use in the shower. Water lube may need reapplication over time but washes off with water, leaving no greasy residue. Neither product has supplied specific cleanup instructions beyond general use, so follow your comfort and hygiene routine.
Toy Compatibility
The supplied information confirms that Water Lube is safe for use with silicone toys. Silicone Lube does not include a similar claim, so if you use silicone-based toys, Water Lube is the recommended choice. For other materials like glass or metal, both lubes are generally compatible, but always check the toy manufacturer's guidelines.
Price and Value
Water Lube is priced at $10.87 (compared to $14.49), while Silicone Lube costs $12.19 (compared to $19.99). The silicone option is slightly more expensive but offers a thicker formula that lasts longer, potentially reducing how much you use per session. The 4 oz bottle of Silicone Lube provides a standard size; Water Lube is available in a standard option.



